Badger 500 Vs. Badger 5 Vs. Badger 1 – Which Is Best Garbage Disposal

The Insinkerator garbage disposals have been in the industry for almost a century. With the changing times, unlike other items that deteriorate in value, Insinkerator keeps getting better. They have mastered their game and are the best.

When it comes to badger 5 and the badger 500, I have done a review of the two just for fun in the past. More people wish to know the differences and the similarities as well as which one is better than the other.

Garbage disposal is vital for any home no wonder the two types badger 5 and 500 are this popular. One characteristic of the badger kind of garbage disposals is that they are cheap. But aside from that, they have a few differences as you will see below.

Product name InSinkErator Garbage Disposal, Badger 5 InSinkErator Badger 500 InSinkErator Garbage Disposal with Cord, Badger 1
Product dimension 7 x 7 x 13 inches 6.3 x 6.3 x 12.6 inches 8 x 8 x 14 inches
HP motor ½ HP ½ HP 1/3 HP
Stages of grinding Single stage Single stage Single stage

1. InSinkErator Garbage Disposal, Badger 5, 1/2 HP Continuous Feed


For most people, this is such reliable garbage disposal that’s easy to install. It has the sink mounting system that if you have read the instructions should be a breeze to install. It further has the quick lock that you use to fit on the mounting.

The badger series are affordable, and it has a compact size. But the main reason anyone would want it so much is that its affordable. It’s also durable since it’s made with the sturdy galvanized steel.

It has a ½ HP dura drive motor to give you a good grind. With this garbage disposal, you can grind even the chicken bones and coffee beans. Although, if you want it to last longer, then you shouldn’t use it for bones and coffee grind.

Unlike others that grind in 3 or 2 stages, this one does it in a single stage. It works on normal leftover foods with ease. The badger is never too powerful, and it’s not large, which makes it ideal for anyone with small households.

The good thing is that it has the stainless steel impellers for grinding which are durable and corrosion-resistant.

For the case of noise: the brand is popular for producing the best noise-free garbage disposals. But that doesn’t mean all of them are noise-free.

Badger 5 is one of the garbage disposals that are not all that quiet but it’s not too noisy either. You can use it even when you have visitors around.

Lastly, badger 5 is most likely the smallest size of disposal in the market. With this product dimensions 7 x 7 x 13 inches, it will fit under any sink with ease. Some people even like to put it on their counter, which is okay too.


  • It’s budget-friendly yet capable of serving those with small families.
  • You can use it with your septic tanks.
  • The gadget will never jam, yet it quickly liquefies your food.
  • It’s easy to install by anyone who can read.


  • It never comes with the pre-installed cord for easy installation. Therefore, you have to buy the cord, which increases the expenses.
  • It’s not one of the quiet appliances at home.
  • While high-end garbage disposals use stainless steel, it uses galvanized steel.

2. InSinkErator Badger 500 1/2 HP Continuous Feed Garbage Disposal


The performance of this badger is almost the same as the one of the badger 5.

It has ½ horsepower, which makes it easy to grind the food together with its stainless steel components. Badger 500 has dura drive induction motor, and with 1725RPM, it will give you a powerful grind.

It doesn’t need the use of a cord to operate; rather, it uses the direct cord method. It processes the food with ease. It will give you a powerful grind but only if you are using it for a limited amount of food waste.

It’s not also one of the quietest badgers that Insinkerator produces. But its reasonably quiet making it easy to operate it even amidst your favorite functions. Its noise isn’t noticeable, which means you can work in the kitchen as its grinding.

It’s more efficient and it has the quick lock sink mount which makes it easy to replace too. The badger is durable and easy to use. Like the one above, this is best suited for anyone with minimal space and just a few people.


  • If you can follow instructions, you will find it easy to install the Badger 500.
  • It’s not as noisy when it’s grinding even though it produces a level of noise.
  • The Insinkerator can grind some hard food like chicken bones. But you shouldn’t use it frequently.
  • It has a 2-year warranty.


  • It never has a power code
  • It then doesn’t work on certain hard food.

3. InSinkErator Garbage Disposal with Cord, Badger 1


Like all badger series, this is easy to install, reliable and functional. Moreover, it has a quick lock sink mount. It’s further one of the cheapest Insinkerator garbage disposal.

With a height of 7.4 inches, you can install it in almost any kitchen, but it’s mostly suitable for those with small kitchens and small spaces.

It fits with most of the Insinkerator hardware, and this makes it easy to install. It has the 1/3 HP dura drive motor together with the galvanized steel which is dependable and durable. Corrosion is off the window with this badger series.

The Badger 5, Badger 1 And Badger 500

The Main Similarities

The most common brand the insinkearator makes them. The brand is known for producing high-quality garbage disposals. This is to say, in buying this brand, you know you haven’t compromised on the quality.

Being the founder of the garbage disposals, you can rest knowing that the brand knows best in this field of the best garbage disposals. The brand produces all the high performing garbage disposals. The badgers are part of them.

The brand also gives it a good reputation, and that means they always satisfy their clientele.

· Small size family

If you have a small family, then consider none other than the badgers since they are smaller in size and suit a small family. They have between 1/3 and ½ HP to grind just a little bit of leftovers.

· User reviews

If you would check in all the major online shops, you will realize that both badger 5 and badger 500 will satisfy you if all you need is low to medium grinding of the waste. They suit anyone that has a small family, and it’s a convenient choice.

Like most other garbage disposals, it will last between 5-10yrs. Notice that most other Insinkerator garbage disposals cost a lot. But it’s all about the features they have. If you, therefore, don’t mind an average kind of disposal go for badgers.

They both cost you very little with badger 5 being even cheaper, and that’s why it’s more accesible. The only thing you should never forget is that you will get what you pay for with this item. Since they are cheaper, you don’t expect so much with them.

· Will they handle solid food waste?

Yes, they break down some form of hardness. For example, they can break down the chicken bone. It can’t handle it over a prolonged time, but it will grind to an acceptable level. In short, if you intend to have the disposal for a longer time, you shouldn’t use the badger for hard bones.

Also, it will let the coffee grinds pass through the chamber but clogging it is possible. They will often form a layer of sediments.

· The noise

The badgers, in this case, are not insulated to reduce the noise as it operates. They will make noise when grinding but it’s not too noisy that you can’t sit in the house as it operates.

· Installation

They both come with all the things you need for the installation process as part of the package. If you have ever installed a badger before, this should be a non-issue to install.

· In performance

The three badgers are the same in performance with each other. For some people, they look the same, and they work the same, which makes them the same, but there is always a slight difference as you will see.

The badger one has a 1/3HP which makes it a little less powerful than the other two, but it can work on the same waste the other two do.

They are both easy to install and change within a few minutes. This means that you don’t need a plumber or electrician to fix it for you.

Also, they all use the continuous feed type method. This makes it easy to continuously breakdown food waste. This method also makes it safe from clogging and jamming. It will work until you stop it, and this makes your kitchen clean with an ambient environment.

They look alike except for the fact that they have badger numbers in bold for you to know what you are buying.

Difference Between Badger 5 And Badger 500

Before we study the differences, let’s agree on the fact that the two are similar in most aspects.

  • They have the same ½ HP
  • The same 1725 RPM
  • They further use the same dura drive motor induction
  • They are both given a 2years warranty.
  • They even look the same.
  • They also have a grinding capacity of 26 inches.

So now you will understand why the customer is confused when they have to buy the badgers. Nevertheless, it still has a few differences.

· The difference in design appearance and the size

In appearance, the two pieces are the same. With your naked eyes, you can’t see much difference except for the fact that the numbers are red for the badger 500 and then white for badger5.

In addition, they have the same weight of 13.6 pounds. It also has almost the same dimension with a minimal difference.

Badger 500 has 6.3 x 6.3 x 12.6 inches

Badger 5 has 7 x 7 x 13 inches

This is an indication that they are both small. They both come in the grey color, which makes them fit in most households.

· Where to shop for it

Unlike the badger 5, the badger 500 is mostly available offline. They ask you to buy it from the brand shops. Although I have seen that Amazon is now selling it, for a long time, they were only sold offline.

On the other hand, badger 5 is available in most online stores. It’s also the reason why it’s one of the most popular types. This makes the badger 5 convenient and readily accessible for most people.

· What of the price

Although we would expect the price to be the same since they are almost the same, they are not. The badger500 costs about $20 more than the badger 5. Again, this makes the badger 5 more popular. Some people make decisions based on the cost.

· The grinding chambers

The weight of the grinding chambers of both the badgers is 26 ounces. With this weight, they grind the leftovers with ease. Nonetheless, the badger 5 chamber is made using stainless steel while badger 500 isn’t.

· The power cord

For the badger 500: If you are installing this in a place where you have the power outlet, it’s sold separately. Nevertheless, the installations are direct wired, but they also don’t use the power cord. This cuts on the cost of buying the power cord.

For the badger 5: you will need the power cord, and for that, you must spend some money on the side.

How to Install a Barger 5 Garbage Disposal


How to Remove A Garbage Disposal

Before you begin the process, you should switch off the garbage disposal from the main switch. So, you must unplug it if it’s plugged into the outlet.

  • With a screwdriver, remove the electrical cover on its bottom then confirm that you have properly switched off the power. Finally, disconnect the wires in the ground.
  • For some garbage disposals, you will have the dishwasher draining into them. You need first to loosen the hose clamp. So, remove the bolts that attached the drainpipe to the unit.
  • Next, there should be the bolts that hold the mounting ring to the disposal. Loosen the bolts but do all this as you are supporting the disposal.
  • Once you have loosened the bolts, begin to turn the mounting ring in an anticlockwise motion. It will become loose and then free.
  • Removing the sink flange: begin to remove the snap ring you will find it in a groove that’s in the flange. You should use the small screwdriver for ease of the process.
  • Once you have removed this snap ring, the mounting bracket and sink flange quickly pulls off.

Badger 1 Vs. Badger 5

It’s safe to say that both of the badgers have their best qualities. For this reason, you can often get confused as to which one to buy.


  • They both use the continuous batch feed method. This is the most popular kind in the market than the batch feed one. You will have to turn them on and off when you wish to use either of them.
  • They come with the open mouth design that lets you drop in the waste every time you are ready. They are further wall mounted.
  • The grinding chamber size is the same. It can only take 26 oz at a time. This means that it’s well suited for those with a few people.
  • They both restrict the kind of food you can push down the chamber. If you continously push hard foods, you will soon damage it.
  • The material that makes the badger 5 and badger 1 is galvanized steel contrary to most garbage disposals that are made using stainless steel. Nevertheless, if you live in a place where the water is not of good quality, it will soon corrode.
  • The noise

Here you have budget-friendly garbage disposals. That means that unlike other Insinkerators, these aren’t insulated. Therefore, noise is inevitable. However, that doesn’t mean that its that absurd noise. You can stand the noise it produces.

  • Other expenses

They both don’t come with a power cord, and that means that you must buy it aside. So that increases the cost of the badger.


· The appearance and size

If you are keen, you will notice that, but for the indicators on the surface of the badgers, they are the same in size. They will always look like the standard sized badger. They both come in black color and have almost the same weight of between 12 and 13.5 pounds.

· The power

The badger 1 has 1/3HP, which is enough to grind the food waste and make it liquid powerfully. But then the badger 5 has ½ HP which makes a little bit more powerful than the badger 1. So, for most people, that’s the main reason why they would prefer badger 5.

It gives you a more powerful grind.

· They have a distinct grinding technology

They work following a single grinding stage not like other Insinkerators that use 2-3 stages to give you a potent grind. It further has a grind shear ring that will make it easy to liquefy your food. Since it becomes liquid, it can easily pass through the pipes.

· The warranty

They both have warranties to keep customers assured of their purchase. But unlike the waste king brand that gives you a long and sometimes lifetime warranty, Insenkerator gives shorter time. The badger 5 gives you a warranty of two years while the badger 1 gives you one year.

· The installation

They are easy to install, but if you need the help of a plumber is still okay for you. They come with the instruction manual to make the installation easy. They come with a quick lock sink mount method which will make mounting the unit easy.

· Problems

If you have made purchases in the past, you should expect nothing to be perfect. For the badger1 and 5 the customers say that with time they begin leaking. But don’t worry, you can solve the issue.

Sometimes it might leak because your sink flange is destroyed from corrosion. This means that you should reseal the disposal afresh using a plumber’s putty.

Other times it may leak because you haven’t tightened the dishwasher and pipes. So, in such cases, tighten it.

Sometimes though, you might have to buy a new one if the inner part of the garbage disposal is leaking.

So, Between the Two Which One Is Best?

If you have been following, you should know that badger 5 is a little more powerful and it has a longer warranty too. This makes it a little better than badger 1.

However, prepare to invest a bit more on the badger if you choose it. Badger 1 is cost-effective.

Which One Should You Choose Between Badger 5 And Badger 500?

These are so similar that we don’t think there’s any difference if you chose one over the other. The reason why I would select badger 5 is that it’s readily accessible, especially when you like ordering things online.

Can I Replace the Badger 1 With the Badger 5?

Yes, you can. They are the same style, so why not. What’s more, they have the same size and specs so you won’t have a problem in the connection. You can also replace the badger 5 with badger 1 after all they use the same power cord.


The badgers have very minimal difference, no wonder most clients don’t know the difference. Some of the difference are, in fact, passable. You can even use one in place of the other because they are very closely related.

In fact, the main difference is that badger 1 has 1/3 HP. Otherwise, they are designed for a small house, and they are both a little noisy. But one thing is true that they will always serve you.